DO AWARD SHOWS NEED TO SORT OUT THEIR DANCE MUSIC CATEGORY?

There’s been a small spat this week, which has been pretty funny if you like that sort of thing. We won’t bore you with all the details, but it involves Charli XCX and John Summit, who have gone toe-to-toe, and of course, Charli’s fans have piled in, as Pop Stans are want to do.

John Summit (dance music) went on X (Twitter) and hit out at being overlooked. He said: “never submitting to the grammys again unless shit changes, it’s all a fucking joke. i’m not just talking about myself either there’s zero respect for real electronic dance music & dj’s. the whole dance category is just music industry fueled pop stars”

He also said: “not saying the artists nominated aren’t good, they’re just not dance music, they’re pop. no dj is playing that music in the clubs.”

Now, if you’re talking about club-clubs, he’s actually correct. However, Charli quote tweeted him and said “not this guy again!”, which is pretty pithy and funny.

There was backtracking, the pop fans found old tweets – you know the drill by now, but Summit added: “logging back on as i realized i didn’t do a good job of making my point earlier. my intent was not to drag other artists down and i seriously congratulate everyone who was nominated. they fully deserve the recognition. i just think there should be an extra category for more dance music djs & producers”

The legendary label Nervous Records got behind this sentiment, saying they’d noticed the lack of representation from clubland, who said that they “understood the need to appeal to the largest audience”, but added that there should be more categories to create more representation for those making house music.

“Yes we should be building our own legit platform award scenario, and yes we should as a community be actively lobbying the Grammys…but still…they can do better,” they shared. “I’m sorry but whoever is involved in presenting these nominations to the voting committee, you’re not paying attention.”

With that, it’s easy to say that you should shut up, and it’s a stoopid award ceremony and who cares what they think, right? However, if you saw the exhaustive list of awards we posted yesterday, you’ll see some very niche categories such as ‘Best Album Notes’, ‘Best Engineers Album (Non Classical)’, ‘Best Chamber Music/Small Ensemble Performance’, and separate awards for ‘Best Arrangement, Instrumental or A Cappella’ AND ‘Best Arrangement, Instruments and Vocals’.

With that in mind, there’s absolutely space to separate the difference between actual club music and pop-dance music, right? Sure, it’s all absolutely meaningless, but in the same way the Oscars routinely ignore Horror movies, the music award shows don’t pay any heed to clubland, and that’s weird given that it’s so vital to the global nightlife and hospitality industry.

Given dance/electronic music’s huge influence on popular music, you’d hope there was a way to give those artists their flowers. There’s the issue of lumping all dance music in the same genre as well, of course, as drum ‘n’ bass and house aren’t related that much, but without them, Madonna and Charli don’t make the albums they’re making – and they wouldn’t debate that either.

As Nervous Records said: “House is a core foundation for a lot of this music, and we are still here. Have not left the building… so I’m sorry but whoever is involved in presenting these nominations to the voting committee, you’re not paying attention.”

Leave a Reply

ThANKS FOR READING